AvatarA monitor of recently published articles, reports, documents and policy briefs relating to Turkey.

Rethinking Turkish-Western Relations: A Journey Without Maps

Download (pdf)
Ian Lesser, GMF Analysis, 30 June 2010

Ninth meeting of the Accession Conference at Ministerial level with Turkey


Download (pdf)
Council of the European Union, Brussels, 30 June 2010


Opened negotiations on Chapter 12 (Food safety, veterinary and phytosanitary policy) of the acquis.

The AKP's Hamas Policy I: How Turkey Turned

Soner ÇağaptayWashington Institute, 29 June 2010

An Evaluation of the Recent Proposal Aiming to Improve Conditions of "Children Throwing Stones to Security Forces" by Amending Certain Statutes

Download (pdf)
Recep Doğan, TEPAV Political Note, 29 June 2010

The Democratic Opening is the Only Way [Turkish only]


Read online
Hatem Ete, SETA, 27 June 2010



Original title: Tek Yol Demokratik Açılım

Ottoman Past Shadows Turkish Present

Read online
Andrew MangoThe Wall Street Journal, 26 June 2010

Turkey, America, and Empire's Twilight

Read online
Conn HallinanFPIF, 25 June 2010

Turkish Government Criticized for its Policy on Kyrgyzstan

Read online
Saban KardasEurasia Daily Monitor 7, no. 123, Jamestown Foundation, 25 June 2010

Interview with Dennis Kucinich


Read online
Gizem Şalcıgil and Nigar GökselTurkish Policy Quarterly, 24 June 2010

The Danger Awaiting Turkey: Clash of Societies [Turkish only]



Hüzeyin Yayman, SETA, 24 June 2010

Original title: Türkiye'yi Bekleyen Tehlike: Halkların Çatışması

Increasing Acts of Terrorism and Measures Taken by the Government [Turkish only]



Sedat LaçinerUSAK Makale, 24 June 2010





Original title: Artan Terör Olayları ve Hükümetin Aldığı Önlemler

Turkey’s exports in Euro and Dollar terms

Read online
Fatih Özatay, TEPAV Commentary, 24 June 2010

Turkey's Iran Policy: Moving Away from Tradition?

Download (pdf)
İlter TuranGMF Policy Brief, 24 June 2010

The Constitutional Court and HSYK in Constitutions and Various Recommendations [Turkish only]


Download (pdf)
Mustafa Şentop, SETA Analiz, 24 June 2010

Original title: Anayasalarda ve Değişiklik Önerilerinde AYM ve HSYK

HSYK is the Supreme Board of Judges and Prosecutors.

Turkey’s Rise and the Decline of Pan-Arabism


Read online
Shlomo Ben-AmiProject Syndicate Commentary, 23 June 2010

Axis Shift in Turkish Foreign Policy [Turkish only]

Download (pdf)
Kürşad Turan, Ortadoğu Analiz 2, no. 18, ORSAM, 23 June 2010



Original title: Türk Dış Politikasında Eksen Kayması

The Time for Action, Not for Hopelessness [Turkish only]


Read online
Özdem SanberkUSAK Makale, 22 June 2010 


Original title: Umutsuzluk Değil Dayanışma Zamanı

A critical look at the still shallow Turkish-Arab rapprochement

Read online
Hasan Kanbolat, ORSAM Analysis, 22 June 2010

The Debate of Axis Shift and Turkey-Middle East Relations


Read online
Veysel AyhanORSAM Analysis, 21 June 2010

Why Turkey is Associated with an Axis Shift?

Read online
Celalettin Yavuz, TÜRKSAM, 18 June 2010

The Collapse of Israel's "Periphery Doctrine": Popping Pipe(s) Turkey Dreams

Read online
Leon Hadar, Cato Institute Op-Ed, 18 June 2010

What Is Happening Between Israel and Turkey?

Read online
İhsan Bal, USAK Article, 17 June 2010

Axis and Turkey: What Should Change?

Read online
Süleyman Özeren, USAK Article, 17 June 2010

All Children Have Rights: End Unfair Prosecutions of Children Under Anti-Terrorism Legislation in Turkey


Northern Iraq Observations 3: How do the Iraqi Kurds Perceive the Developing Relations with Turkey?


Read online
Oytun OrhanORSAM Analysis, 16 June 2010

Turkish-Azeri Deal May Herald New Competition in Southern Corridor

Read online
Saban KardasEurasia Daily Monitor 7, no. 130, Jamestown Foundation, 15 June 2010

Stealth Superpower

Read online
John FefferFPIF, 14 June 2010

Who Lost Turkey? Not Europe

Read online
Doug Bandow, Cato Institute, 14 June 2010

The Gaza Flotilla Raid and its Aftermath

Read online
Bülent Alirıza, Stephen Flanagan and Haim Malka, CSIS Turkey Project, 14 June 2010

Israel’s Attack on the Aid Flotilla and the New Middle East


Read online
Mehmet ŞahinORSAM Analysis, 14 June 2010

Barzani in Ankara: Normalization of Relations, Distancing from PKK

Read online
Mehmet Yegin, USAK Article, 11 June 2010

Is There a Chance for Liberal Left in Turkey?

Read online
İhsan Bal, USAK Article, 11 June 2010

The End of Deference: Iran, Brazil and Turkey and the Nuclear Fuel Swap

Read online
Ian Anthony, Real Instituto Elcano, 11 June 2010

Talking Turkey about Turkey

Read online
Leon Hadar, Cato Institute, 9 June 2010

In the midst of a flurry of policy briefs and commentaries on the Gaza flotilla crisis and the new regional order it heralds, Hadar's article is a refreshing reality check for the most part. Warning academics and journalists to avoid the "broad brush" when hastily painting new narratives to explain current events, he gives some needed background on Turkey's relations with Israel and its overall role in the region, debunking the widespread idea that Turkey is an Islamic fundamentalist regime aimed at rebuilding the Ottoman Empire. He also points out the hypocrisy of some US policymakers who are now fear mongering about the AKP and Turkey after praising them for the past eight years.

Hadar concludes:
...The current crisis also demonstrated the need on the part of the Israelis and the Turks to refrain from turning these policy disagreements into a wide-ranging "civilizational" conflict. Israel needs to recognize and support Turkey's determination to play a more activist diplomatic role and take advantage of it and refrain from trying to demonize Turkey as an Islamofascist entity. At the end of the day, Israel has more at stake than Turkey in repairing the bilateral relations between Ankara and Jerusalem. 
This last sentence is certainly true. But I don't see a huge risk for this issue-based conflict to evolve into an identity one, much less anything on the "civilizational scale." While Turkish public opinion is outspokenly opposed to the policies and actions of the Israeli government, it seems to stop there: there is little new support for anti-Semitic sentiments or movements against the existence of Israel, though their existing supporters may have grown louder.
At the same time, Erdogan and the AKP should understand that that Turkey does not have the capability to serve as an all powerful regional hegemon, and that any attempt to move in that direction will ignite anti-Turkey backlash from regional and global players. In any case, trying to serve as a mediator between the Israelis and the Arabs could prove to be a difficult and thankless job — if not a mission impossible — as the Americans and other powers have already discovered, and that trying to compensate for their diplomatic weakness by displaying Islamist bravado could backfire against the Turks and will certainly not accelerate the establishment of a New Middle East anytime soon. In short, Turkey is not as threatening as its detractors warn nor as powerful as many Turks and their new fans believe.
I'm not sure where Hadar is getting this 'New Middle East' concept or who has been pushing that particular narrative, but it sounds much more American than Turkish to me. And who are these "new fans" of Turkey supposed to be? I don't know about them, but according to the polls of the PewResearchCenter, Turks are more likely to say that their country is disliked around the world than to say it's liked -- in fact, they are the only nationality besides Americans to do so. While nationalism is alive and well in Turkey, so is disillusionment and pragmatism; Hadar's warnings about the nation's limitations would not fall on deaf or naive ears.

Blaming Turkey

Read online
John FefferFPIF World Beat, 8 June 2010

Economic and Defense Ties Between Turkey and Israel in Crisis

Read online
Saban KardasEurasia Daily Monitor 7, no. 109, Jamestown Foundation, 7 June 2010

Who's Afraid of Turkey?

Soner Çağaptay, Washington Institute, 4 June 2010

Lose-Lose for Turkey and Israel?

Soner ÇağaptayWashington Institute, 4 June 2010

Iraqi Kurdish Regional Government's President Massoud Barzani's Speech at ORSAM

Download (pdf)
ORSAM Events, 4 June 2010


In his speech, Barzani reiterated his commitment to nonviolence and the unity of Iraq. When asked about the PKK and cooperative counter-terrorism efforts between Iraq and Turkey he gave no direct answer, instead praising the Turkish government's largely undefined and ineffective 'Kurdish opening' policy. Mr. Barzani stated that the Iraqi Kurds would not ally themselves with the Shias in any attempt to politically marginalize the Sunnis, or vice versa. He offered no information on the planned free trade zone between Turkey and the KRG.

Turning against US


Read online
Judith Miller and David SchenkerWashington Institute Op-Ed, 3 June 2010

Turkey: Landmark Convictions in Torture Case


Managing a More Assertive Turkey

Read online
Bernard Gwertzman, Council on Foreign Relations, 3 June 2010


An interview with Stephen Larrabee.

The aftermath of Israel's raid on the Gaza aid flotilla: Is Turkey a new rogue state?

Daniel Steinvorth, EUISS Opinion, June 2010

AKP's "new" foreign policy between vision and pragmatism

Download (pdf)
Heinz Kramer, SWP Working Paper, June 2010